James Trafford has been given his chance to become England's No1, and the Leeds United goalkeeper is grabbing it with both hands. The 24-year-old produced a stunning performance against Spain in Madrid on Sunday night, making a string of crucial saves to help England secure a famous 3-2 victory. His heroics have strengthened his case to replace Jordan Pickford as Thomas Tuchel's first-choice goalkeeper.
Trafford's finest moment came deep into stoppage time when he produced a remarkable double save to deny Spain an equaliser. With England desperately holding on to their narrow lead, the youngster showed incredible reactions to keep out two close-range efforts and preserve the victory. He finished the night with six saves and was named Player of the Match as England ended Spain's 43-game unbeaten run.
How James Trafford and Jordan Pickford Compare in Statistics
It was another huge statement from Trafford, who has been handed an opportunity by Tuchel and has done little to suggest he should give up the gloves. And while the German boss has refused to publicly name his first-choice goalkeeper, his decision to start Trafford ahead of Pickford in such a huge game suggests the balance could be shifting. Tuchel said afterwards, There's no number one. It's a good double save. That's what we wanted. He had a brilliant match.
Trafford again! 👊🏻
— ITV Football (@itvfootball) November 15, 2026
An excellent double save from the Leeds United keeper 🙌 pic.twitter.com/L27oQFQO1J
England’s number one? 🤔
— ITV Football (@itvfootball) November 16, 2026
A look back at some of James Trafford’s saves from last night 🔥 pic.twitter.com/BLEMO1YAsD
Their individual data show the Leeds goalkeeper has been outperforming his Everton rival in several key areas for England. The figures, covering their respective appearances against Czechia, Spain and Croatia in September and October, make interesting reading. Both goalkeepers played 180 minutes during that period, but Trafford faced nine shots on target compared to just five for Pickford.
Shot-Stopping Metrics and Expected Goals Data
The former Manchester City goalkeeper made eight saves, twice as many as Pickford's four. That gave Trafford an impressive save percentage of 88.9 per cent, compared to Pickford's 80 per cent. The numbers become even more encouraging for the Leeds star when looking at the quality of chances he has faced.
Trafford prevented 0.8 goals according to Opta's expected goals on target conceded metric, while Pickford prevented just 0.2. It means Trafford has been stopping more goals than the quality of opposition shots would suggest he should. His performances against Spain have been particularly impressive, with the youngster making six saves in September's meeting between the two countries.
He followed that up with another six in Madrid on Sunday, including the dramatic late double stop that left his England team-mates rushing to congratulate him. His form for Leeds this season has been just as impressive in domestic competition.
Domestic Premier League Form for Leeds and Everton
Trafford has prevented 4.4 goals in the Premier League, conceding eight from shots worth 12.4 expected goals on target, putting him top of the division for that measure. Pickford, meanwhile, has conceded ten goals from shots worth 11.05 expected goals on target, giving him a goals-prevented figure of 1.05. That is another area where Trafford is outperforming his more experienced rival and strengthening his case for the England shirt.
However, Pickford still holds the upper hand when it comes to distribution at international level. The Everton goalkeeper completed 63 of his 80 passes during the two games covered by SunSport's Opta figures, giving him a passing accuracy of 78.8 per cent. Trafford managed just 35 successful passes from 54 attempts, with an accuracy of 64.8 per cent.
Pickford also completed 20 long passes compared to Trafford's seven, with the Everton man's long-pass accuracy standing at 54.1 per cent against his rival's 26.9 per cent. At 32, Pickford has the experience of 94 England caps and several major tournaments behind him. But Trafford, eight years his junior, represents both the present and potentially the long-term future for England.
What Thomas Tuchel Has Said About the Goalkeeper Battle
His performances have given Tuchel a genuine selection dilemma, particularly with the Leeds goalkeeper showing he can deliver against the very best opposition. The England boss was also impressed by Trafford's composure in possession against Spain, praising his ability to help the Three Lions play through the hosts' pressing.
Tuchel said, The obvious save, where he deserves full credit, is the double save at the very end. Absolutely brilliant. And with England's Nations League quarter-finals coming up in March, Trafford has given his manager every reason to keep faith with him.
Pickford has been a reliable servant for England for years but the numbers and Trafford's heroics in Madrid suggest his position is no longer guaranteed.