How Missing Out on Lewis Hall Impacted Manchester United

Luke Shaw was clocked at Manchester United's training ground last week and it remains to be seen if he clocks back on now Mauricio Pochettino is the manager. Shaw gushed in Pochettino's 2017 book that he hoped to play for him again. That was the year that Jose Mourinho pushed Shaw to fourth in the United left-back pecking order.

It says more about United than Mourinho that Shaw, 31, has survived Mourinho, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, Erik ten Hag, Ruben Amorim and Michael Carrick after two contract renewals five years apart. His longevity would suggest Shaw has been integral to a successful spell. In fact, he has played in one of the five cup finals United have won in his 12-and-a-half years at the club.

Shaw has managed five appearances from 15 this season, a predictably derisory return. He started in all 38 Premier League games last season but that achievement was tempered by the light workload. With the fixture schedule more relentless with United back in the Champions League, Shaw was one of the first flies to drop. He has sustained two separate injuries.

The Injury Woes and Squad Deficits

When his absence was first noticed in early September, United figures said Shaw was on a rest day. It was quite a long rest. Shaw did not play in the next three games and he has managed two outings since then. Shaw has appeared 330 times for United but missed 334 of their games. Figures at the club already appear unfit for purpose if they have not decided to release Shaw when his contract expires in June then they are more lacking in fitness than the left back.

Senior figures at United privately rue the failure to have signed Lewis Hall in the summer, whom senior figures at Newcastle now claim is not going anywhere soon. Hall was seething at his World Cup squad omission, blamed Eddie Howe for mismanaging him and had spent three years at Newcastle. In days gone by, Hall would have been easy pickings for United. Yet they dithered, partly due to the inability to shift Marcus Rashford.

United wanted a left-sided reinforcement but could not finance a deal for a winger and a left back. By the time they accepted that they were saddled with Rashford, also crocked for over a month, and enquired about Hall, Newcastle had sold three other players for more than £200million. Hall stayed.

Contract Situations and International Rise

Hall has since signed a new contract, which hardly safeguards his Newcastle future. He will have banked a significant salary increase and it would be remiss for any 21-year-old footballer to say no when there is no guarantee that they will move onto pastures new in a year's time. Had Hall declined Newcastle's offer and sustained a serious injury, he would be looking at a loss of income into the millions. His contract has merely been extended by two years, too.

Having kept Lamine Yamal in check in England's uplifting win against Spain, Hall can now be considered England's starting left-back. Hall brimmed with the purpose, alacrity and athleticism in Madrid that United were often devoid of when they played at Atletico's stadium last month. United were given advance notice of Hall's talent, too. He was excellent for Chelsea at Old Trafford in May 2023 and six months later scored at the stadium for Newcastle in a 3-0 League Cup stroll, which was his first ever senior goal.

That defeat reduced United's supine starting left back, Sergio Reguilon, to tears in the dressing room. When United required an emergency left back to offset another injury to Shaw at the start of that season, it came down to Reguilon or Marc Cucurella. Cucurella has since won the European Championship and World Cup and joined Real Madrid. Reguilon had his season-long loan terminated early by United, was released by Tottenham and is now at Inter Miami. This happens too often with United for it to be bad luck.

Defensive Shortages and Financial Consequences

With Shaw out, United do not actually have a senior recognisable left back. Michael Carrick played two right backs and a centre back there whilst Harry Amass, an actual left back, never got a start. In fairness to Carrick, when he told us in early August he was after two more signings, it was in reference to a midfielder and a left back. He got Carlos Baleba but not Hall.

Hall's renewal has already cost United as he could easily command a world-record fee for a full back next year. Lucas Hernandez, the current holder of that title from his 2019 transfer to Bayern Munich, cost £68m. Newcastle bank big fees for big players including Alexander Isak, Anthony Gordon, Sandro Tonali and Bruno Guimaraes, and Hall belongs in that bracket. Add the England tax increase and his value is the best part of £100m.

United need an entirely new back four next summer and that is likely to set them back the best part of £200m. They remain responsible for the most expensive defender of all time in Harry Maguire, an £80m purchase in 2019. Shaw got injured at the start of that season, too.