The Auditor General of Pakistan released its latest audit report showing the federal government spent Rs. 41,335.729 billion in FY2024-25, exceeding the approved budget by Rs. 1,990.501 billion, or about 5.06 percent.

Debt servicing accounted for Rs. 34,851.682 billion, or 84.31 percent of total outlays, leaving just Rs. 6,484.047 billion (15.69 percent) for all other federal functions.

How the Overspend Was Calculated

The audit compared the final approved budget of Rs. 39,345.228 billion with actual expenditures recorded for the fiscal year. The difference of Rs. 1,990.501 billion represents the amount by which the government went beyond its sanctioned limits.

Debt servicing includes both interest payments of Rs. 8,998.449 billion and principal repayments of Rs. 25,853.234 billion. These figures are drawn directly from the Treasury's accounting statements and verified by the Auditor General's independent review.

What the Debt Servicing Share Means for Public Services

With more than four-fifths of the budget allocated to debt obligations, the remaining funds for health, education, infrastructure and social safety nets are severely constrained. Analysts note that a 15.69 percent share for all non-debt items is historically low for Pakistan, where previous fiscal years typically allocated around 30 percent to development and welfare spending.

The limited pool of Rs. 6,484.047 billion must cover the salaries of federal employees, operational costs of ministries, and capital projects. This compression forces ministries to prioritize essential services and defer many planned initiatives.

Supplementary Grants: Large Amounts Unapproved by Parliament

The audit uncovered that 92 percent of supplementary grants issued in FY2024-25 lacked parliamentary approval. Out of Rs. 3,461.830 billion in supplementary grants, Rs. 3,177.682 billion remained unapproved.

Furthermore, the government sought an additional Rs. 3,809.190 billion without a thorough assessment of actual financial needs, raising concerns about fiscal discipline.

Other grant-related findings include:

  • Exceeding final approved grants by Rs. 187.680 billion.
  • Rs. 87.336 billion lapsed across 115 cost centres because allocated funds were not used.
  • Rs. 41.682 billion in supplementary grants remained unspent.

Tax Collections and Federal-Provincial Transfers

Federal tax collections rose 26.26 percent to Rs. 11,674.641 billion compared with Rs. 9,246.168 billion in FY2023-24. Despite the increase, the federal government transferred Rs. 6,583.984 billion to provinces under the National Finance Commission (NFC) Award.

After the NFC transfer, the net federal tax revenue available for central spending stood at Rs. 5,090.657 billion.

The audit also highlighted a discrepancy between the initial budget provision of Rs. 43,438.864 billion and the final approved amount of Rs. 39,345.228 billion after budget surrenders and supplementary grants were accounted for.

Weaknesses in Financial Controls and Missing Records

The report identified 78 cases of weak internal controls, specifically pointing to missing records for amounts deposited into government employees' General Provident Fund (GP Fund) accounts.

It also flagged a transfer of Rs. 7.498 billion from the Federal Consolidated Fund to the Public Account, prompting questions about the handling of public money.

Audit observations led to the recovery of Rs. 2.26 billion, showing that some irregularities were corrected after the audit findings were communicated.

Recommendations and Next Steps

The Auditor General recommended that serious cases involving alleged embezzlement be referred to investigation agencies for further action. It also directed all government departments to ensure that public funds are not spent without the required parliamentary approval.

Implementation of these recommendations will involve the Ministry of Finance tightening expenditure controls, the Parliament reviewing the status of unapproved supplementary grants, and audit institutions monitoring compliance in subsequent fiscal years.

Historical Context of Pakistan's Fiscal Challenges

Pakistan has faced persistent fiscal deficits for decades, often financing gaps through external borrowing. Debt servicing has therefore become a growing share of the budget. According to the State Bank of Pakistan, external debt stock reached over US$115 billion in early 2024, driving up interest obligations.

Previous Auditor General reports have repeatedly highlighted weaknesses in budget execution, but FY2024-25 marks the first time debt servicing exceeded 84 percent of total expenditure, according to the current audit.

Implications for Stakeholders

For ordinary citizens, the constrained non-debt budget may translate into reduced public services, slower infrastructure development, and limited social welfare payouts. Businesses may face higher taxes or reduced government contracts as the fiscal space narrows.

Provincial governments, while receiving a sizable share of tax collections through the NFC Award, may also feel the pressure of reduced federal transfers for joint projects.

What to Watch for Going Forward

Key indicators to monitor include:

  1. The Parliament's response to the 92 percent of unapproved supplementary grants.
  2. Any corrective legislation or policy changes announced by the Ministry of Finance.
  3. Subsequent audit reports for FY2025-26 that will reveal whether the identified weaknesses have been addressed.
  4. The trajectory of debt servicing as external borrowing costs evolve.

Stakeholders are advised to keep an eye on official statements from the Auditor General's office and the Ministry of Finance for updates on corrective actions.