Former Manchester United captain Paul Ince says Mauricio Pochettino has the "nous" to succeed at Manchester United and rejects the notion that the job is a poisoned chalice.
Why Ince's Comments Matter Now
Ince made his remarks as Pochettino arrived in Manchester on Wednesday and prepared for his first training session on Thursday, ahead of United's Premier League clash with Liverpool on Sunday. The timing is crucial because United sit 18th in the league, a position lower than when Southampton appointed Pochettino in January 2013.
Background: Pochettino's Path to Old Trafford
Mauricio Pochettino, 54, has managed four Premier League clubs - Southampton, Tottenham Hotspur, Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea - before being linked to United for more than a decade. Sources say he entered serious contention only in the last few weeks after Michael Carrick was dismissed, despite a two-and-a-half-year hiatus from club management.
His most recent achievement was guiding the United States to the World Cup last-16 in the summer, a performance that raised his profile internationally. At Tottenham he oversaw the development of players such as Harry Kane, Dele Alli and Mousa Dembélé, earning a reputation for nurturing talent.
What Ince Said About Pochettino's Character
Ince, 59, praised Pochettino's personality, saying: "I've met Pochettino a few times, a lovely, lovely man. Really, really kind, humble man, very approachable." He added that a brief 20-minute conversation covered "football, X, Y and Z" and affirmed that "he's a top, top manager."
He continued: "I hear these words about it being a poisoned chalice, which is mad. You're at one of the biggest clubs in the world, and it's the poisoned chalice managing Manchester United? It's bizarre."
Ince's Critique of United's Current Situation
Ince blamed United's poor form on "terrible" recruitment and decision-making from the hierarchy. He argued that the club needs someone with "a bit of nous" and believes Pochettino fits that description.
He questioned the fitness regime, noting United are 19th out of 20 clubs for total distance covered this season. He contrasted this with former manager Michael Carrick, who did not employ a dedicated fitness coach and gave players a day off after matches, versus previous managers such as Ruben Amorim, Erik ten Hag, Jose Mourinho and Louis van Gaal, who insisted on recovery sessions.
Fitness Staff Changes Under Pochettino
Pochettino will bring his son Sebastiano and Silvia Tuya as fitness coaches, expanding United's back-room team. At Tottenham he oversaw six fitness coaches, indicating a more scientific approach to conditioning.
Ince's Specific Concerns About Player Work-Rate
Ince highlighted United's 1-1 draw at Fulham on 20 September as a turning point. He said: "From the kick-off that Fulham had, they had 46 passes and a shot on goal without a Manchester United player touching the ball." He described the lack of involvement as "unheard of" and warned that "the players see it, the players say, 'We're not working hard enough'."
He added: "I don't believe a player ever goes on to the pitch and says, 'I'm not going to work hard, I'm not going to try for the team'. I could never envisage a player thinking that way." He warned that players might "run around like lunatics to show they're working hard" only to be "picked off" later, suggesting a mismatch between effort and effective performance.
What the Appointment Means for United's Transfer Policy
Pochettino's track record of developing young talent could influence United's upcoming transfer window. His experience at Tottenham, where he signed and sold players profitably, may lead to a more measured spending strategy compared with recent high-profile, high-cost signings that have not delivered expected returns.
What Comes Next for United
United's next match against Liverpool on Sunday will be the first real test of Pochettino's impact. The club's hierarchy has not publicly disclosed whether Pochettino has full authority over recruitment, but Ince asked, "Has he got carte blanche on what he does? To say, 'I'd bring the players in, I'd do this'?"
Fans and analysts will watch the training sessions on Thursday for clues about tactical shifts, fitness drills, and any changes in player roles. The club's performance metrics - distance covered, pass completion, and pressing intensity - will likely be scrutinised to gauge whether the new fitness regime yields immediate improvements.
In summary, Ince's endorsement adds a former player's perspective to the growing narrative that Pochettino could restore discipline, fitness and strategic clarity to a struggling Manchester United side.