Federal Board of Revenue Restructuring Sparks Warnings Over Informal Economy

The decision by the Federal Board of Revenue to separate income tax and sales tax administration could encourage businesses to remain outside the tax net and expand Pakistan's informal economy, the Policy Research Institute of Market Economy has warned. This structural change reverses a policy enacted seventeen years ago in 2009, which unified income tax, sales tax, and federal excise collections under the Inland Revenue Service. That previous arrangement aimed to reduce duplication, improve compliance, and allow a single tax officer to handle all aspects of a company's tax affairs. Analysts and economic researchers are closely examining the potential consequences of this division as tax authorities grapple with persistent revenue shortfalls.

Last week, the Federal Board of Revenue officially separated sales tax and federal excise administration from income tax within the Inland Revenue Service. Dr. Muhammad Sarmad Qureshi was appointed the first Member of Sales Tax and Federal Excise Duty, while Muhammad Anwar was named chief of these taxes. A separate stream of officers is expected to become operational next month, marking a significant shift in how tax returns are processed and audited across the country. Business owners and fiscal policy experts are now assessing what these changes mean for day-to-day operations and compliance burdens.

Background on the 2009 Tax Reform and Functional Integration

To understand the weight of the recent restructuring, it helps to examine the architecture of Pakistan's tax administration prior to 2009. For decades, distinct departments handled direct taxes like income tax and indirect taxes like sales tax independently. This meant businesses often dealt with multiple inspectors, conflicting directives, and redundant paperwork. The 2009 reform introduced functional integration within the Inland Revenue Service, consolidating collection under one umbrella. The core idea was that cross-referencing data within a single office would make tax evasion harder and reduce administrative overhead for both the state and registered corporations.

The Federal Board of Revenue justified the latest restructuring by pointing to weak domestic sales tax collection figures. Official data showed that domestic sales tax collection declined by 1.7 percent during the last fiscal year, even though collections at the import stage grew by 17 percent. Tax authorities argued that specialized departments could focus more intently on specific revenue streams and reverse the domestic collection slump. However, independent economists and research organizations have questioned whether dividing the apparatus addresses the root causes of the collection deficit.

How Separate Tax Streams Could Weaken Evasion Checks

The Policy Research Institute of Market Economy argued that separating tax administration would weaken an important mechanism for detecting evasion because businesses report overlapping financial information in their income tax and sales tax returns. A company concealing sales to reduce its sales tax liability could also be hiding income. When one officer handles both taxes, identifying discrepancies in one return can expose evasion in the other. Separate officers could weaken this connection, according to the think tank.

Under a unified system, data cross-matching serves as an automated and human-verified safeguard against fraud. When different departments operate in silos, the friction between separate offices can lead to missed signals and uncoordinated audits. Tax evasion schemes often exploit gaps between different revenue heads, making integrated oversight a vital tool for investigators. Splitting the personnel into distinct streams risks recreating the bureaucratic disconnect that the 2009 reforms were specifically designed to eliminate.

Impact on Registered Businesses and Compliance Costs

The institute warned that manufacturers, importers, and distributors already registered with the Federal Board of Revenue could face two commissioners, separate notices, and different interpretations of the same transactions. Instead of dealing with a single point of contact for corporate tax matters, taxpayers may now find themselves answering to multiple authorities with potentially misaligned priorities. This fragmentation increases the administrative burden on compliant businesses, which already operate in a challenging economic environment.

Meanwhile, businesses operating outside the tax net would avoid these additional compliance requirements entirely. The increased cost and complexity of registration could discourage more businesses from entering the formal economy, defeating broader state objectives to broaden the tax base. Manufacturers and merchants weighing the costs of formalization may view the added bureaucratic friction as a strong incentive to remain informal and cash-based.

Broader Economic Challenges and the Cash Economy Debate

These administrative concerns coincide with broader scrutiny of Pakistan's financial ecosystem and heavy reliance on cash transactions. National Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Authority Chairman Mushtaq Sukhera identified reliance on cash transactions as a major driver of illicit financial activity during a Senate committee briefing. He reported that a policy paper proposing a transition toward a digital economy had been submitted to the government to curb unregulated capital flows.

During the same committee proceedings, lawmakers raised pointed questions about enforcement practices and internal governance. Senator Dilawar Khan cautioned tax authorities against aggressive enforcement measures that could unnecessarily target legitimate taxpayers. He stated that money laundering notices were being issued to individuals and businesses already registered with the Federal Board of Revenue, creating unwarranted panic among compliant citizens. Senator Abdul Qadir also criticized corruption within the tax administration, referring to a recent controversy at the Regional Tax Office in Lahore involving a dispute over the distribution of bribe money.

Structural Flaws in Value-Added Tax and Tax-to-GDP Ratios

The Policy Research Institute of Market Economy also argued that fragmented value-added tax administration was a major obstacle to better collection. Goods are taxed federally, while services fall under provincial authorities, creating separate rates, returns, exemptions, and regulatory requirements. This constitutional division between federal and provincial tax collection creates enduring compliance challenges for businesses operating across jurisdictional boundaries.

The institute said a harmonized value-added tax covering goods and services, with a lower unified rate and fewer exemptions, would improve revenue collection more effectively than another administrative restructuring. The think tank added that Pakistan's tax to GDP ratio remained at 10.3 percent during the past two fiscal years despite repeated reforms and billions of dollars in loans, highlighting the continued challenges facing the country's tax system. As policymakers weigh further interventions, the debate over administrative structure versus fundamental tax harmonization remains central to Pakistan's economic trajectory.