More than half of tobacco farmers surveyed in Pakistan reported selling their crops to buyers without direct written agreements, highlighting significant gaps in compliance with Pakistan Tobacco Board regulations and raising concerns about the potential flow of tobacco leaf into the illicit supply chain. The findings come from a detailed examination of agricultural practices in key growing regions, shedding light on how crops move from fields to processing facilities and highlighting structural challenges within the local economy.

An independent study by the Institute for Public Opinion Research, titled Assessment of Tobacco-Leaf Production, Marketing and Purchasing Practices in Pakistan, surveyed 1,200 tobacco farmers across Swabi, Mardan, and Charsadda. It examined purchasing agreements, pricing, payment methods, and compliance with existing regulations to understand the economic pressures facing rural cultivators and the broader implications for state oversight.

More Than Half Sell Without Written Agreements

The study found that 52 percent of farmers sold tobacco to buyers with whom they had no direct written agreement. Additionally, 45 percent had no written purchasing agreement before planting. These numbers point to widespread informality in an agricultural sector that is supposed to operate under strict government supervision.

Under the existing Pakistan Tobacco Board regulatory framework, tobacco purchases are subject to government-notified weighted average price requirements intended to protect farmers. Tobacco companies and dealers are also required to meet their announced purchasing quotas, including additional surplus quantities assigned by the board. Cultivators often rely on these structured quotas to secure predictable incomes for their families and to plan their next planting season.

The study found considerable differences in the prices farmers received from different buyers. Those selling to multinational tobacco companies received an average of PKR 720 per kilogram, compared with PKR 559 from other companies and PKR 471 from dealers. Among farmers who experienced difficulties selling tobacco outside formal agreements, 85 percent reported receiving offers below the official Pakistan Tobacco Board price.

Cash Payments Raise Supply Chain Concerns

Payment practices emerged as another area of concern for market watchers and regulatory officials. Among farmers selling through non-contracted arrangements, 52 percent reported receiving payments in cash, while 36 percent said they were paid immediately at the time of purchase. While cash offers immediate liquidity to rural workers, it complicates efforts to track financial flows and taxable revenues.

The study said such practices weaken transparency and traceability, particularly when tobacco is purchased directly without passing through designated buying depots. These arrangements point to a parallel gray market operating outside the oversight of the Pakistan Tobacco Board. Without proper paper trails, verifying the final destination of agricultural output becomes extremely difficult for state inspectors.

The findings raise concerns about enforcement efforts as the government works to curb illicit tobacco trade. Weak oversight at the beginning of the supply chain could create opportunities for tobacco leaf to enter undocumented and potentially illicit distribution channels. Tax authorities have long sought to close loopholes that allow untaxed goods to bypass national revenue collection systems.

Understanding the Regulatory Framework and Market History

The tobacco sector in Pakistan is heavily regulated due to its economic importance and public health implications. The Pakistan Tobacco Board operates as the central regulatory body tasked with fixing prices, overseeing production quotas, and mediating between growers and manufacturing firms. Historically, the agency was established to ensure that farmers receive fair compensation for their labor while preventing monopolies or predatory buying practices by large corporations.

Despite these statutory protections, compliance has remained uneven across different provinces and districts. Rural communities in regions like Swabi, Mardan, and Charsadda depend heavily on tobacco cultivation as a primary source of household income. When formal buyers limit their intake or when quotas are insufficient, desperate cultivators often turn to informal middlemen who offer quick cash despite paying lower rates per kilogram.

Market analysts note that informal trading networks have persisted for decades despite repeated policy updates. These networks thrive during periods of economic uncertainty when farmers face rising costs for seeds, fertilizers, and fuel. Understanding the persistence of informal sales requires examining the financial vulnerability of smallholders who cannot afford to store harvested leaves while waiting for official buyers to open purchasing depots.

Economic Impact on Local Communities and National Revenue

The prevalence of informal sales affects multiple tiers of the economy, starting with the individual farmer and extending to national fiscal health. When cultivators accept below-market prices from third-party dealers, their profit margins shrink, limiting their ability to invest in modern farming techniques or improve living standards. Over time, this dynamic can discourage younger generations from continuing family farming traditions.

From a macroeconomic perspective, undocumented tobacco leaf movements deprive the state of crucial tax revenue. Tobacco products are subject to heavy federal excise duties, and any leakage at the agricultural production stage undermines the entire taxation architecture. When raw leaf enters the gray market, it often resurfaces in illicit cigarette manufacturing operations that sell cheap, duty-free products to consumers.

Business associations and agricultural advocacy groups frequently debate the balance between stringent enforcement and supporting rural livelihoods. While stricter policing of buying depots can curb illegal leakage, it must be accompanied by measures that expand formal purchasing quotas. Otherwise, farmers left without legal outlets will continue to rely on informal buyers out of financial necessity.

IPOR Calls for Stronger Regulatory Enforcement

Commenting on the findings, IPOR Executive Director Tariq Junaid said gaps in compliance with existing regulations were creating uncertainty for farmers and increasing the risk of below-market payments. He stressed that formalizing the supply chain is essential for protecting vulnerable workers from exploitation.

The issue is the gaps in compliance with the regulatory framework governing tobacco purchasing, Junaid said. When tobacco is traded outside formal agreements through third-party buyers, farmers face greater uncertainty and the risk of receiving prices below those prescribed by the Pakistan Tobacco Board. Stronger enforcement of existing regulations is essential to address these gaps.

The study also found that 62 percent of farmers considered increased purchasing agreements or higher procurement quotas from multinational companies the most important improvement needed in the existing system. Cultivators view formal corporate contracts as a reliable shield against price volatility and unreliable middleman networks.

Junaid said greater buyer accountability, stronger oversight of purchasing quotas, and improved access to formal agreements were essential to protecting farmers and ensuring a fair and transparent tobacco market. The study recommended stronger compliance with existing Pakistan Tobacco Board laws and regulations, greater accountability across all purchasing channels, and improved traceability of tobacco leaf transactions to protect farmers interests and government revenue.

What Lies Ahead for Pakistan Tobacco Regulation

As policymakers review the findings from Swabi, Mardan, and Charsadda, attention will likely turn toward how the Pakistan Tobacco Board plans to enforce its own guidelines. Observers will be watching for potential policy updates regarding mandatory registration of buyers and stricter penalties for entities operating outside approved purchasing depots. Effective reform will require cooperation between federal regulators, agricultural extension officers, and major manufacturing firms.

For rural communities, the immediate concern remains crop pricing and securing stable contracts before the next planting cycle begins. Ensuring that multinational and domestic companies fulfill their allocated quotas will be vital in reducing reliance on informal dealers. Stakeholders across the agricultural sector hope that increased public scrutiny will lead to a more transparent and orderly market for all participants.