How Newcastle United Rejected Alex Scott to Protect Elliot Anderson
Newcastle United abandoned a move for Alex Scott because they did not want to block Elliot Anderson's pathway, it has been revealed. Then Toon sporting director Dan Ashworth, who is now the FA chief football officer, blocked the £18million switch to take Scott from Bristol City so as not to impact Anderson's development.
Former Toon head of recruitment Steve Nickson, now at Wrexham, divulged the information on a podcast for his new club. Anderson was coming through the Magpies academy and would go on to join Nottingham Forest and then move in the summer for £116million to Manchester City, while Scott left the Robins to join Bournemouth and is of serious interest to Chelsea in January.
Inside the Decision by Dan Ashworth and Steve Nickson
Nickson detailed the internal discussions surrounding the aborted transfer during a recent appearance on a podcast. The former recruitment head recalled the exact rationale used by the club hierarchy when evaluating the Bristol City midfielder against their own internal talent.
Nickson said, "I remember we were looking at Alex Scott at that time. Dan Ashworth stopped, at £18m, and said: 'What does he give us that Elliot can't?' He would have blocked Elliot's pathway. We kept Elliot, we always would have, but his path would have been blocked, you have to open that up. Elliot had good people around him, if young players aren't with good people they can fall off the rails."
This calculated risk by the recruitment department ensured that internal academy graduates retained a clear route to the first team. Rather than spending funds on an external prospect with a similar profile, the club opted to back their own homegrown talent.
The Career Trajectories of Elliot Anderson and Alex Scott
The decision proved pivotal for the subsequent career paths of both young midfielders. Anderson progressed through the ranks at St James' Park before securing a transfer to Nottingham Forest, followed by a high-profile move to Manchester City for £116million. At 24 years of age, he has established himself as a regular fixture in the international setup under Thomas Tuchel, becoming one of the German manager's trusted options in midfield.
Scott departed Bristol City for Bournemouth, where his performances continued to attract widespread attention from elite clubs. Born in Guernsey, the 23-year-old midfielder has seen his valuation rise significantly. Bournemouth retained his services during the summer transfer window, but the south coast club could prove open to a sale in January for the £85million-rated player. Chelsea previously had a bid rejected in the summer and are expected to renew their pursuit when the transfer window opens. Liverpool are also monitoring the situation closely, aided by the connection to manager Andoni Iraola, who previously managed Scott at the Cherries.
International Partnership and Future Prospects
Despite taking different club routes, Scott and Anderson forged a strong partnership at international level. They became best pals playing together for England's Under-21s at the Euros in the summer of 2025, helping Lee Carsley's Young Lions win the competition.
Their chemistry on the pitch was evident during a stellar display together on Scott's first start alongside Anderson in a 7-0 thrashing of Croatia in Rijeka last month. Though a red card against Spain means Tuchel will have to draft in a different player for the Nations League quarter-finals in March, that replacement could well be Scott. The Guernsey-born midfielder continues to knock on the door of the senior squad, vindicating the early assessments made by recruitment staff at both club and international levels.