Understanding the Youth Unemployment Crisis in Modern Britain

Finding a first job is a memorable milestone for any young person. My own first job was waitressing in a local pub, which taught me essential life lessons that no classroom can provide, such as turning up on time, handling difficult customers, and understanding the value of money earned through personal effort. You cannot get on in life if you do not get a start in life, yet too many young people today are being denied that crucial opening.

Alan Milburn, the former Labour minister who led the Government-commissioned review into the welfare system, deserves credit for saying what too many in the Labour Party have ignored. A whole generation is being written off by this government. Almost a million young people aged 16 to 24, which translates to roughly one in eight, are not in education, employment, or training, known as NEETs.

Youth unemployment has reached 15.6 per cent, a worse rate than seen in Bulgaria, Slovenia, or Hungary. Behind those numerical figures are real people who send off application after application and hear nothing back from employers. Parents are left to watch a bright son or daughter lose a little more confidence every month as they remain locked out of the workforce.

How Business Taxes and Red Tape Destroy Entry-Level Positions

Alan Milburn's earlier report recognised a truth many Labour MPs are in denial about, namely that it has become too expensive for many businesses to hire young people. Labour's jobs tax has made it more expensive to hire staff, and their Employment Rights Act has made companies think twice before taking someone on. Consequently, young people have been hit hardest by these economic pressures.

Retail and hospitality have always been the traditional sectors where young people get their first start, much like my own early experience. But right now, those businesses are closing their doors at an alarming rate. In the first nine months of this year, almost 300 pubs have closed, which represents a rate of around one a day across the country.

Restaurants and hotels will tell you how badly they are feeling the squeeze too, and each closure knocks another rung off the bottom of the employment ladder. The Conservatives agree with Alan Milburn on the nature of the problem, and we want his review to succeed. Where we disagree is on the cure, which is why we have set five tests to judge whether Labour's approach is up to the challenge of the moment.

Evaluating Government Spending and Subsidised Work Placements

The proposals trailed so far could mean six billion pounds of extra government spending. One big-ticket item looks likely to be subsidised work placements intended to make up for the jobs that Labour policies have destroyed. Killing jobs and then spending billions of pounds to recreate them is the epitome of the government knows best approach.

Our first test is therefore whether the review cuts the costs on businesses so they can create real jobs for young people. The second half of the problem is that our welfare system makes it too easy for people to stay out of work. If welfare is too attractive, those who can work may choose not to do so, and too many young people are now beginning adult life on benefits.

That situation gives rise to our second and third tests: will a young person who refuses to work have their benefits cut, and will the review reduce the number of young people dependent on the welfare state? Over a year ago, we set out our plans to stop giving cash benefits for mild health conditions and move to treatment and support instead, ensuring financial help is targeted for those with serious illnesses and disabilities.

Welfare Reform and Financial Savings Proposals

It looks like Alan Milburn will copy that policy, and if so, that is a positive development. This approach should apply to people already claiming benefits, irrespective of their age, which forms our fourth test. We have identified thirty-six billion pounds in welfare savings, and if the Government is not willing to reduce spending on welfare, then it is simply not being serious.

Our final test is the simplest of all: will it get the working-age welfare bill down overall? If you can work, you should work. But bringing down the welfare bill remains a big stumbling block for Labour MPs. As we know from the Welfare Secretary's messages, all Labour MPs want to do is put up taxes to spend more money on benefits.

Sir Keir Starmer U-turned on welfare reforms, leaving many to wonder if figures like Andy Burnham have the backbone to stay the course. Conservatives have alternative plans to help young people because we know that businesses, rather than government agencies, create actual jobs. Our plan would halve the jobs tax for under-25s, saving an employer around one thousand five hundred pounds a year for every young person they take on.

Alternative Proposals for Apprenticeships and Welfare Control

We would also cut business rates for two hundred and fifty thousand High Street shops, pubs, and hospitality businesses, which are the places most likely to give a teenager their first shift. Furthermore, we would create one hundred thousand new apprenticeships every year, with firms paid up to five thousand pounds for each young apprentice they take on and train.

Our Get To Work programme would end the drift from education straight into long-term welfare dependency. No young person will be able to leave school or college, sign on to Universal Credit, and then sit at home while public money goes directly into their bank account. We will also cut away the red tape that has strangled summer and Saturday jobs, because the government must get out of the way.

Alan Milburn is barking up the right tree with his diagnosis, and on welfare he has borrowed a good deal of Conservative medicine. If Labour wants to help this generation, it should stop taxing the jobs they need and start backing businesses to employ them, while also stopping paying them to stay at home. What young people want is a real job and the chance to prove themselves, not subsidised placements that leave them sitting back at home when the placement ends. If you can work, you should work, and the job of the government is to clear the way for the businesses that make that possible.