A new study presented at the FPCCI regional office in Lahore reveals that Pakistan's 9 pm shop-closing rule, introduced to conserve electricity, has cut daily customer transactions by 42 percent and trimmed average operating hours, while most retailers report little or no reduction in their own electricity bills.
What the Study Measured and Who Took Part
The research, titled The Impact of Early Closing Time Regulations on Pakistan's Retail Sector, draws on a mixed-method survey of 1,046 consumers, 300 retailers operating in 53 malls and markets across ten cities, and 25 key informants from industry bodies and policy circles. The authors also benchmarked Pakistan's policy against early-closing regulations in 15 other countries.
Key Findings on Operating Hours and Transaction Volume
Average daily operating hours fell from 11.2 to 9.6, a loss of 1.6 hours per day. During the same period, daily transactions per outlet dropped from 86 to 50, representing a 42 percent decline. The study links the drop directly to the loss of evening trade, which historically accounted for a large share of footfall.
How the Evening Window Was Affected
Retailers who previously reported heavy traffic between 4 pm and 8 pm fell from 63 percent to 32 percent. A senior executive in the footwear and apparel segment explained that 40 to 50 percent of daily footfall arrives between 7 pm and 9 pm - the window now closed by the regulation.
Retailer Responses and Adaptations
In reaction to the reduced hours, about 73 percent of surveyed retailers have opened earlier in the day, 34 percent have started or expanded online sales, and 12 percent have reduced staff levels. Industry representatives cautioned that online sales are not compensating for the loss of walk-in customers.
Consumer Impact: Time Constraints and Shopping Frequency
More than half of consumers (53 percent) said finding time to shop has become harder, especially for office workers who finish around 6 pm. Average monthly shopping trips fell 7 percent overall, while women's trips fell 19 percent, dropping from 7.2 trips per month to 5.8.
Changing Shopping Habits
The share of people who rarely or never shop with family rose from 62 percent to 71 percent, and those who rarely or never shop for leisure rose from 74 percent to 87 percent. Preference for neighbourhood shops increased from 27 percent to 31 percent, while preference for malls slipped from 8 percent to 6 percent.
Public Opinion and Retailer Sentiment
Consumer opinion is split: 35 percent support the early-closing rule, 33 percent are neutral, and 32 percent oppose it. Among retailers, half (50 percent) are opposed. Although 56 percent of retailers believe the energy-saving goal was achieved, only 41 percent reported actual savings on their own electricity bills.
International Benchmark: How Other Countries Handle Retail Hours
Of the 15 countries examined, only Pakistan and Bangladesh restrict shop hours specifically to save energy. Bangladesh has altered its rules seven times since April. Brazil achieved a reduction of over 20 percent in retail electricity use by imposing electricity quotas rather than changing opening hours. France's retail-efficiency measures saved around 15 percent without altering shop-closing times.
Consultation Gaps and Adjustment Timelines
Ten of the 25 key informants said traders were not consulted before the decision was made. One executive warned that businesses need four to six weeks to adjust, but the rules were changed again before that window elapsed.
Recommendations from Stakeholders
Stakeholders called for a consultative process with traders, an extension of closing times to 10 pm or 11 pm, direct targeting of energy use through solar power and loss-reduction programmes, and the introduction of sector-specific and seasonal relief measures. The authors stress that evidence-based communication and policy advocacy, backed by trader consultation, are essential for any future revisions.
What This Means for the Retail Sector Going Forward
The study suggests that the early-closing rule has disrupted traditional retail patterns without delivering the promised electricity savings for most merchants. Retailers are experimenting with earlier openings and digital channels, but these adjustments have not yet closed the revenue gap. Policymakers face a choice: maintain the current schedule and risk continued sales erosion, or revise the rule in line with the study's recommendations to balance energy goals with sector viability.
Practical Takeaways for Retailers and Consumers
Retailers should assess the cost-benefit of extending opening hours versus investing in energy-efficient technologies such as LED lighting and solar panels. Consumers may need to plan shopping trips earlier in the day or shift to neighbourhood stores that remain open later. Both groups can benefit from monitoring upcoming policy announcements, as the government is expected to review the rule before the end of the fiscal year.