Young people with conditions such as ADHD and autism will be expected to work under proposals in a landmark review - and receive less in benefits.
Jobs tsar Alan Milburn insists in his report that intervention must occur earlier to give affected youths a route into work or training.
The Labour grandee says those with conditions may "get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim than under the current system".
He adds: "Britain has built a service designed to diagnose and treat illness. It needs to intervene earlier."
Mr Milburn says those with conditions "often end up trapped on benefits, when under the new system they would be both expected and enabled to be in work".
His recommendations include a single youth allowance which will be set at the standard rate of Universal Credit - in major changes to health and disability benefits,
But The Joseph Rowntree Foundation say young people could lose out on £50 per week for losing the health element of UC.
They could also lose between £30 and £195 a week if they are stopped from claiming Personal Independence Payment.
Mr Milburn says that for every £25 spend on benefits for under-25s only £1 is spent on employment support.
He says the changes should bring that ratio down from £2 to £1 within ten years.
He says: "The system I propose will spend less on compensating for economic inactivity, more on creating routes out of it; less on the consequences of failure and more on avoiding it.
"I am unapologetic about advocating that the State should spend more to set young people up for a successful life earning or learning rather than spending decades with their sole income from benefits.
"That is the choice I believe is the right one for this and future generations of young people."
His review also says that Ministers must take swift action against private firms diagnosing ADHD and autism after a huge surge in cases.
NHS funding should be restricted or withdrawn from firms that fail to meet required standards.
The wanting from Alan Milburn comes as the number of young people set to claim disability benefits expected to quadruple between 2012 and 2037.
He says the new system will actively help affected people into work in the welfare shake-up.
The jobs tsar is demanding a major change in his landmark review into so-called NEETs - those not in education, employment or training.
He says that action should be taken against the independent sector diagnostic market.
Milburn says the process must begin immediately and by 2028 new payment mechanisms should be in place.
He says they should be based on "quality and outcomes" rather than just assessment and how many tests are carried out.
The landmark report reveals that conditions such as anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism among NEETs account for almost two in three of all new claims.
The report starkly shows that the disabled working-age population went up by 17 per cent between 2019 and 2024.
But at the same time there was a 46 per cent rise in the number claiming incapacity or disability benefits.
He says: "To put it at its simplest, the growth in benefits far outweighs the actual change in ill-health and disability among young people."
What Does the Review Propose for Universal Credit and PIP?
The central recommendation is a single youth allowance set at the standard Universal Credit (UC) rate. Under the proposal, the health element of UC - which currently adds extra weekly support for those with diagnosed health conditions - would be removed for eligible youths with ADHD or autism. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation estimates that this removal could cut up to £50 per week from a claimant's income.
In addition, the review suggests that Personal Independence Payment (PIP), the disability benefit that provides extra money for daily living and mobility needs, could be denied to some young claimants. The potential loss ranges from £30 to £195 per week, depending on the level of entitlement previously awarded.
Why Is Early Intervention Emphasised?
Milburn argues that the current system spends disproportionately on compensating for inactivity rather than on preventing it. He cites a spending ratio: for every £25 spent on benefits for under-25s, only £1 goes to employment support. The review targets a reduction of this ratio from £2 to £1 within ten years, meaning more resources would be allocated to training, apprenticeships, and job placement services.
Early intervention, according to the report, means diagnosing and supporting young people before they become entrenched in the benefits system. By shifting focus from assessment to outcomes, the government would aim to create a "route into work or training" rather than a "trap on benefits".
Background: Rising Disability Claims Among Young People
The review notes a dramatic demographic shift. Between 2012 and 2037, the number of young people expected to claim disability benefits is projected to quadruple. Data also shows that the disabled working-age population grew by 17 per cent between 2019 and 2024, while claims for incapacity or disability benefits rose by 46 per cent in the same period.
Among NEETs - individuals not in education, employment or training - mental health conditions such as anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism now account for almost two-thirds of all new benefit claims. This concentration suggests that a relatively small set of diagnoses is driving a large share of welfare expenditure.
How Will the New Payment Mechanisms Work?
Milburn calls for new payment mechanisms to be in place by 2028. These mechanisms would shift from a purely diagnostic-based model to one that rewards "quality and outcomes". In practice, this could mean that funding to private diagnostic firms is tied to measurable success rates, such as the proportion of diagnosed youths who secure employment or complete training within a set timeframe.
The review also recommends that NHS funding be restricted or withdrawn from private firms that fail to meet required standards. This leverages the public health system's purchasing power to enforce quality across the diagnostic market.
Impact on Affected Young People
If implemented, the proposals could reduce weekly income for eligible youths by up to £245 (£50 from UC health element plus up to £195 from PIP). For many families, this represents a material loss that could affect housing, food security, and access to therapies.
Conversely, the review promises greater investment in employment support services. Young people who receive tailored training, mentorship, and job placement assistance may experience improved long-term earnings and reduced reliance on benefits.
What Comes Next?
The review is a government-commissioned document, but it does not carry the force of law. Implementation will require legislative changes to the Universal Credit framework and to PIP eligibility criteria. Ministers will need to draft statutory instruments, and the proposals will be debated in Parliament.
Stakeholders such as disability charities, youth organisations, and private diagnostic firms are expected to submit evidence during the consultation period. The government has indicated that the process must begin immediately, with the aim of having the new payment structures operational by 2028.
Watch for:
- Parliamentary debates on amendments to UC and PIP rules.
- Responses from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation and other advocacy groups.
- Guidelines from the Department for Work and Pensions on how "quality and outcomes" will be measured.
Practical Takeaways for Readers
Young people with ADHD or autism and their families should review their current benefit statements to understand how a potential loss of the health element or PIP could affect them. Seeking advice from a benefits adviser now could help mitigate any future shortfall.
Employers and training providers should prepare for increased demand for youth-focused employment programmes, as the government signals a shift toward more active labour-market support for this group.
Finally, anyone involved in private diagnostic services should audit their compliance with NHS standards, as future funding may be contingent on meeting stricter quality metrics.