The Senate Standing Committee on Cabinet Secretariat was told on Wednesday that 95 government officials have admitted to holding dual nationality, prompting the government to draft legislation that would bar civil servants from possessing foreign citizenship.

The disclosure came from National Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Authority (NAML&CTA) Chairman Mushtaq Sukhera, who said a policy paper proposing the ban has already been forwarded to the cabinet for consideration.

Why the Ban Is Being Considered

Chairman Sukhera argued that civil servants who hold foreign citizenship are in a position to facilitate corruption and move illicit wealth abroad. He warned that dual nationality creates a conflict of interest that could undermine the integrity of the public service.

Senator Rana Mahmoodul Hassan echoed those concerns, calling for close scrutiny of officials who acquire foreign permanent residency or citizenship through investment schemes. He said such schemes often lack transparency and can be used to conceal the origin of illegally obtained funds.

Legal Framework and Proposed Exceptions

Cabinet Secretary Kamran Ali Afzal supported the need for comprehensive legislation that would establish a clear legal framework governing foreign citizenship among civil servants. He emphasized that any law must also define possible exceptions, such as individuals who acquire foreign citizenship by birth.

Afzal noted that the Establishment Division has already introduced rules that require civil servants to obtain government permission before applying for foreign nationality. Those rules, however, are procedural and do not constitute a blanket ban.

Senator Abdul Qadir backed the push for stricter legislation, stating that the current ad-hoc approach does not deter officials from seeking dual nationality.

Background on Dual Nationality in the Civil Service

Pakistan permits dual nationality with a limited list of countries under the Citizenship Act of 1951, but civil servants have historically been required to seek approval before acquiring a second passport. The policy was intended to prevent conflicts of interest in sensitive ministries such as foreign affairs, defence, and finance.

In recent years, the number of officials applying for foreign citizenship has risen, partly due to investment-based citizenship programmes offered by countries in the Caribbean and Europe. These programmes allow individuals to obtain a passport by making a qualifying financial contribution, a route that some civil servants have reportedly used.

Impact on Federal Employment and Regional Representation

During the same committee meeting, senators discussed the representation of Balochistan in federal jobs. Senator Abdul Qadir proposed a special five- to ten-year employment package to boost Balochistan's presence in the civil service.

Establishment Secretary Barrister Nabeel Ahmad Awan said a proposal to increase the province's quota by reallocating one percent each from Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa is under consideration. He added that 12,000 jobs have been allocated for Balochistan, including 5,500 for its southern districts.

Senator Dilawar Khan raised concerns about a shortage of senior police officers in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and questioned the recent transfers of three officers from Swabi, Charsadda, and Haripur. He urged a review of the Hard Area Policy and a reconsideration of those transfers.

What the Proposed Legislation Would Entail

If enacted, the legislation would make it unlawful for any civil servant to hold foreign citizenship unless a specific exemption is granted by the government. Violations could lead to disciplinary action, including dismissal, and could trigger a review of the official's financial disclosures.

The bill is expected to include provisions for:

  • Mandatory declaration of any foreign citizenship or permanent residency upon appointment and annually thereafter.
  • Requirement to surrender foreign passports or obtain a waiver from the Ministry of Interior.
  • Clear criteria for exemptions, such as birth-right citizenship in a foreign country.
  • Penalties ranging from salary suspension to termination of service.

Procedural Steps and Timeline

The policy paper has been submitted to the cabinet, where it will be reviewed by the Cabinet Committee on Governance. Once the cabinet approves the draft, it will be presented to the National Assembly for debate and voting.

After parliamentary approval, the law will be gazetted and the Establishment Division will issue detailed implementation guidelines. Civil servants will likely be given a transitional period, estimated at six months, to disclose existing foreign citizenships and apply for exemptions where applicable.

Potential Challenges and Criticisms

Critics argue that a blanket ban could discourage qualified Pakistanis who hold dual nationality from serving the state, especially in diaspora communities that bring valuable expertise. Human rights advocates caution that the law must respect constitutional protections against discrimination.

Legal experts also note that the proposed ban may clash with existing provisions of the Constitution that guarantee the right to acquire foreign nationality, unless a clear exception for public servants is articulated.

What Citizens and Officials Should Watch For

Stakeholders should monitor the cabinet's decision on the policy paper, the subsequent parliamentary debate, and any official notifications from the Establishment Division. Officials currently holding dual nationality will need to prepare documentation for either surrendering foreign passports or applying for the limited exemptions outlined in the draft.

Employees in provinces with special quota considerations, such as Balochistan, should watch for updates on the proposed reallocation of quotas, as that could affect recruitment and promotion cycles.

Finally, the Senate's discussion on the Hard Area Policy signals that the government may also review deployment strategies for senior police officers in conflict-prone regions, an issue that could intersect with the broader civil service reform agenda.

Overall, the proposed ban on dual nationals in the civil service reflects a growing governmental emphasis on transparency, anti-corruption measures, and the alignment of public-sector employment with national security concerns.