Why Manchester United Should Have Hired Mauricio Pochettino Years Ago

Mauricio Pochettino is the right man to take over at Manchester United. That would have been an accurate statement in 2018, and in 2019, and in 2020, and 2021, but not now. It would be typical of these decision-makers to turn to a man who was sounded out by Ed Woodward while Omar Berrada and others were still on the Manchester City payroll.

Pochettino has not managed at club level since he left Chelsea in June 2024. He has had a mixed time with the United States national side, humbled by Belgium on home soil in the World Cup round-of-16. It is not unfair to suggest Pochettino, 54, is past his peak in the Premier League. A source said he was weirdly desperate to return to Tottenham this year.

You may have seen the video of Pochettino on a Madrid-bound flight, revelling in Tottenham fans chanting his name. He is magic, you know, Mauricio Pochettino. Coincidentally, it is to the same tune as Michael Carrick's chant that United fans have been belting out.

The History of Missed Opportunities With Mauricio Pochettino

It is rather fitting that Pochettino is attracted to another club morphing into relegation fodder. United has been Pochettino's white whale for more than a decade. United considered Pochettino as the frontrunner to replace Jose Mourinho in December 2018, but an approach was planned at the end of the season. Come March, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer had been upgraded from caretaker manager.

Pochettino wanted the United job after Spurs dismissed him in November 2019. United had four wins from their first 14 Premier League games, but Solskjaer staved off the threat of Pochettino with back-to-back wins against Mourinho's Tottenham and City. A year later, United discreetly contacted Pochettino's representatives in the wake of the 6-1 thrashing by Spurs. Again, they dithered, stuck with Solskjaer, and an impatient Pochettino ended a 13-month spell out of work by replacing Thomas Tuchel at Paris Saint-Germain.

Pochettino was an early favourite when Solskjaer was finally jettisoned in November 2021. United approached Paris Saint-Germain, who knocked back the enquiry. It would also have cost £15 million to release Pochettino from his contract, but with Ralf Rangnick in interim charge for the remainder of the season, Pochettino was a possibility for the following campaign.

How Erik Ten Hag and Other Factors Kept Pochettino Away

Pochettino lost in another two-horse race as United football director John Murtough opted for Erik ten Hag. Pochettino was the players' preferred choice, but United settled on Ten Hag in mid-March 2022. Paris Saint-Germain's remarkable collapse against Real Madrid in the Champions League was a nail in Pochettino's coffin. His unwillingness to openly agitate for United also counted against him.

When Ten Hag was confirmed in April 2022, it felt that the United ship had sailed for Pochettino when it seemed he would inevitably sail into United. If United are as big as they think they are, they would not settle for the trophy-less Pochettino. His coaching club honours came at Paris Saint-Germain, where the kit man could manage them to the Ligue 1 title. Pochettino's Tottenham lost League Cup and Champions League finals, two FA Cup semi-finals, and came third in a two-horse title race in 2016.

Why the Past Dominates Manchester United Decision-Making

As brilliant a job as Pochettino did in transforming Spurs into a credible force, he was sacked seven years ago. His Tottenham tenure is borderline irrelevant in an ever-changing Premier League landscape. One figure would approve if Pochettino is driven into Carrington. Sir Alex Ferguson wined and dined Pochettino in London in May 2016, a desperate final attempt by the Scot to block Mourinho's imminent appointment.

Ferguson had told the Tottenham MP David Lammy at a dinner three months earlier that Pochettino was the best coach in the Premier League. He was happy for Lammy to make that public as United had touched base with Mourinho. The celebrations surrounding the 40th anniversary of Ferguson's appointment were the latest fix for the nostalgia-addicted United. It would be fitting if the club stuck in the past made an appointment they should have made eight years ago.